Vol. 3 No. 4 (2024): caring for nurses
Articles

The effectiveness of nursing in intermediate care related to an integrated concept of dependency: a case study using the Modified Barthel index

PDF
  • Sara Falchi,
  • Silvio Quirini,
  • Nikita Valentina Ugenti,
  • Yari Longobucco,
  • Sandra Scalorbi
Sara Falchi
Home Care Nursing, Savena Santo Stefano District, Local Health Authority (AUSL) of Bologna, Bologna, Italy
Silvio Quirini
IRCCS University Hospital of Bologna, Bologna, Italy
Nikita Valentina Ugenti
Department of Medical and Surgical Sciences, University of Bologna, Italy
Yari Longobucco
Department of Health Sciences, University of Florence, Florence, Italy
Sandra Scalorbi
IRCCS University Hospital of Bologna, Bologna, Italy
DOI: https://doi.org/10.36253/if-1667

Published 2024-12-31

Keywords

  • Intermediate Care,
  • Transitional Care,
  • Barthel Index,
  • Nursing Planning

Copyright (c) 2024 Sara Falchi, Silvio Quirini, Nikita Valentina Ugenti, Yari Longobucco, Sandra Scalorbi

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Abstract

Introduction. A new care setting was established In modern society, called intermediate care (IC). It refers to residential structures aimed at link hospital and patient’s home, ensuring improved and personalized continuity of care and achieve better health outcomes. Patients admitted in this setting are usually elderly, with high levels of dependency. One of the most used assessment tools for dependency is Barthel Index (BI) and its modified version: the Modified Barthel Index (MBI). The aim of this paper is to verify if care in community hospital (intermediate care) improves patient independence (measured with Modified Barthel Index), and this improvement is linked to an appropriate care model.

Methods. A case study of a hypothetical patient has been developed, according to the Rosenberg Model. Data emerging from the case study has been compared with international literature. Care dependency is very a broad concept and includes both objective data and patient’s perceptions. Care dependency, therefore, could be described and assessed from an objective and a subjective point of view, in term of person’s affect. The case-analysis provides possible indicators regarding the meaning of dependency and is the start point for a targeted assessment of Nursing Diagnoses (NDs).                                                                                                                                         

Results. The functional domains of NANDA-I taxonomy 2024-2026 related to dependency were identified through the case analysis. Each ND was examined with reference to objective and subjective diagnostic indicators, thus highlighting the diagnoses related to each 14-independence topic presented by Hillcoat-Nallétamby. The MBI has been used as nursing outcome together with other psycho-social indicators.

Discussion. MBI is proved to be an indicator of the effectiveness of nursing care provided in the intermediate care settings. However, in order to define a patient as independent, the physical domain should be integrated with his/her psychosocial experiences according to identified Nursing Diagnosis.          

Conclusion. An integrated nursing assessment leads to the identification of the Nursing Diagnosis influenced by the experience of dependency. Nursing Plan should include patient’s emotions and other aspects related to his/her social life.

PDF

References

  1. Gobbens RJJ, Maggio M, Longobucco Y, Barbolini M. The Validity of the SUNFRAIL Tool: A Cross-Sectional Study among Dutch Community-Dwelling Older People. J Frailty Aging. 2020; 9:219-225
  2. Levin KA, Crighton E. Measuring The impact of stepdown intermediate care on delayed discharge: an interrupted time series analysis, J Epidemiol Community Health. 2019; 73:674-679
  3. Waydhas C, Herting E, Kluge S, Markewitz A, Marx G, Muhl E, Nicolai T, Notz K, Parvu V, Quintel M, Rickels E, Schneider D, Steinmeyer-Bauer KR, Sybrecht G, Welte T. Intermediate care units: Recommendations on facilities and structure. Med Klin Intensivmed Notfmed. 2018; 113:33-44
  4. Comodo N, Maciocco G. Cure intermedia: basi concettuali. Prospettive sociali e sanitarie. 2004; 3:1-3.
  5. Torres OH, Francia E, Longobardi V, Gich I, Benito S, Ruiz D.. Short- and long- term outcomes of older patients in intermediate care units. Intensive care med. 2006; 32:1052-1059
  6. Pianori D, Avaldi VM, Rosa S, Lenzi J, Ialonardi M, Pieri G, Rossi A, Fantini MP.How do Community Hospitals respond to the healthcare needs of elderly patients? A population-based observational study in the Emilia-Romagna Region. Annali di Igiene. 2018; 30:317-329.
  7. Bartoli S, Ferro S e De Palma R. Le cure intermedie come soluzione per affrontare le malattie croniche: il programma Stroke Care, Italian Journal of Medicine, 2012; 6:139-143.
  8. Harris R, Wilson-Barnett J, Griffiths P. Effectiveness of nursing-led inpatient care for patients with post-acute health care need: secondary data analysis from programme of randomized controlled trial, Journal of Evaluation in clinical Practise. 2007; 13:198-205.
  9. Young JB, Robinson M, Chell S, Sanderson D, Chaplin S, Burns E, Fear J. A whole system study of intermediate care services for older people, Age and Ageing. 2005a; 34:577-583.
  10. Young JB, Robinson M, Chell S, Sanderson D, Chaplin S, Burns E, Fear J. A prospective baseline study of frail older people before the introduction of an intermediate care service. Health and social care in the community. 2005b; 13:307-312.
  11. Dijkstra A, Buist G, Dassen T. Operationalization of the concept of ‘nursing care dependecy’ for use in long-term care facilities, Australian and New Zeland Journal of Mental Health Nursing. 1998; 7:142-151.
  12. Orem DE. Nursing: concetti di pratica professionale. 4th ed. Summa; 1992.
  13. Henderson V. The Nature of Nursing: a Definition and its Implications for Practice and Education. Macmillan; 1966.
  14. Bizier N. Dal pensiero al gesto: un modello concettuale di assistenza infermieristica, 2nd ed. Sorbona; 1993.
  15. Hillcoat-Nallétamby S. The Meaning of “Independence” for Older People in Different Residential Settings, Journal of Gerontology, serie B: Psychologial Sciences and Social Scieces. 2014; 69: 419-430.
  16. Piredda M, Matarese M, Mastroianni C, D'Angelo D, Hammer MJ, De Marinis MG. Adult Patients’ Experiences of Nursing Care Dependence, Journal of Nursing Scholarship. 2015; 47:397-406.
  17. Zürcher, S.J., Vangelooven, C., Borter, N., Schnyder, D., Hahn, S. Psychometric testing of the Italian and French versions of the care dependency scale. J. Adv. Nurs. 2016; 72:3207–3215.
  18. Piredda M, Candela ML, Marchetti A, Biagioli V, De Maria M, Facchinetti G, Albanesi B, Iacorossi L, De Marinis MG. The Care Dependency Scale: A cross validation study in inpatients with cancer. Eur J Oncol Nurs. 2022; 56:102087.
  19. Piredda M, Bambi S, Biagioli V, Marchetti A, Ianni A, Lusignani M, Rasero L, Matarese M, De Marinis MG. Cross-validation of the Care Dependency Scale in intensive care unit (ICU-CDS). Intensive Crit Care Nurs. 2020; 57:102787.
  20. Bouwstra H,Smit EB, Wattel EM, van der Wouden JC, Hertogh CMPM, Terluin B, Terwee CB.Measurement properties of Bathel Index in Geriatric Rehabilitation. JAMDA. 2018; 20:420-425.
  21. Ohura T, Hase K, Nakajima Y, Nakayama T. Validity and reliability of a performance evaluation tool based on the modified Barthel Index for stroke patients. BMC Med Res Methodol. 2017; 17:131.
  22. Al-Khawaja I, Wade DT, Turner F.The Barthel Index and its relationship to nursing dependecy in rehabilitation. Clinical Rahabilitation. 1997; 11:335-337.
  23. Griffiths P, Wilson-Barnett J, Richardson G, Spilsbury K, Miller F, Harris R. The effectiveness of intermediate care in a nursing-led in-patient unit. Int J Nurs Stud. 2000; 37:153-61.
  24. Dahl U, Steinsbekk A, Johnsen R. Effectiveness of an intermediate care hospital on readmissions, mortality, activities of daily living and use of health care services among hospitalized adults aged 60 years and older – a controlled observational study, BMC Health Service Research. 2015; 15:351-362.
  25. Kaambwa B, Bryan S, Barton P, Parker H, Martin G, Hewitt G, Parker S, Wilson A. Costs and health outcomes of intermediate care: results from five UK case study sites. Health and social care in the Community. 2008; 16:573-581.
  26. Green J, Young J, Forster A, Mallinder K, Bogle S, Lowson K, Small N.. Effect of local based community hospital care on independence in older people needing rehabilitation: randomized controlled trial. British Medical Journal. 2005; 331:317-326.
  27. Dixon S, Kaambwa B, Nancarrow S, Martin GP, Bryan S. The relationship between staff skill mix, costs and outcomes in intermediate care services. BMC Health Services Research. 2010; 10:221-228.
  28. Ter Maten-Speksnijder AJ, Dwarswaard J, Meurs PL, van Staa A. Rhetoric or reality? What nurse practitoners do to provide self-management support in outpatient clinics: an ethnographic study. Journal of Clinical Nursing. 2016; 25:3219-3228
  29. Griffiths P, Harris R, Richardson G, Hallett N, Heard S, Wilson-Barnett J. Substitution of a nursing-led inpatient unit for acute services: randomized controlled trial of outcomes and cost of nursing-led intermediate care. Age Ageing. 2001; 30:483-8.
  30. Rosenberg JP, Yates PM. Schematic representation of case study reserarch designs, J Adv Nurs. 2007; 60:447-452.
  31. T. Heather Herdman, Shigemi Kamitsuru, Camila Takáo Lopes (Eds.), NANDA International, Inc.: Nursing Diagnoses: Definitions and Classification 2024-2026, Thirteenth Edition © 2024 NANDA International, ISBN 978-1-68420-601-8
  32. Shah S, Vanclay F, Cooper B. Improving the sensitivity of the Barthel Index for stroke rehabilitation. J Clin Epidemiol. 1989; 42:703-709.