Philosophy of Sport. A Critical Review of Contemporary Debates
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.36253/rifp-3686Keywords:
sport, inclusion, doping, fandom, e-sportsAbstract
Although sport is a social practice with a long history and one that now holds a certain more or less direct relevance in the lives of many people, the philosophical analysis of this phenomenon is fairly recent. While some contributions were presented as early as the 1930s, the philosophy of sport as an autonomous discipline only developed from the 1970s onward. Whereas the earliest contributions were situated within the philosophy of education and regarded sport as a vehicle for the formation of the individual, more recent literature has begun to apply philosophical methods and concepts to every domain of sporting practice. As we shall see in this brief and inevitably partial reconstruction of the debate, in recent years metaphysical, ontological, aesthetic, ethical, and political questions have been examined. Although the topics addressed are many, those that will be analyzed in greater detail concern the nature of sport, doping, fandom, and the inclusion of women. The final section deals with two areas – esports and combat sports – that are emerging and will, in our view, undergo significant development in the coming years.
Downloads
References
Abanazir, Cem. “Institutionalisation in e-sports”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 13 (2019): 117-131.
Abanazir, Cem. “Of values and commercialisation: an exploration of esports’ place within the olympic movement”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 16(4), 2022, 397-412.
Altman, Matthew “Reframing the debate over performance-enhancing drugs: The reasonable athlete argument. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 19(2), 2025, 171-184.
Andersen, Wivi. “Sport and self-love: reflections on boxing and the construction of selfhood”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 48(1), 2021, 129-145.
Aranyosi, István. “Body, skill and look: is bodybuilding a sport?” Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences, 17(2), 2018, 401-410.
Archer, Alfred, and Georgina Mills. “Foul-weather fandom”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 50(3), 2023, 383-401.
Archer, Alfred, and Jake Wojtowicz. “It’s much more important than that: against fictionalist accounts of fandom”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 49(1), 2022, 83-98.
Archer, Alfred, and Jake Wojtowicz. Why It’s OK to be a Sports Fan. London: Routlegde, 2023.
Archer, Alfred. “Fans, crimes and misdemeanors: Fandom and the ethics of love”. The Journal of Ethics, 25(4), 2021, 543-566.
Arielli, Emanuele. “Reality, Fiction, and Make-Believe in Kendall Walton”. The Palgrave Handbook of Image Studies. Cham: Springer International Publishing, 2021, 363-377.
Artis, Aderemi. “Children and mixed martial arts”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 16(4), 2022, 607-622.
Bai, Jiangzhu, Xiaotian Wei, and Rongting Zhou. “The etymological evolvement and redefinition of ‘game’”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 19(1), 2025, 35-47.
Bartezaghi, Stefano. Chi vince non sa cosa si perde. Milano: Bompiani, 2024.
Bastianon, Stefano, Corrado Del Bò (a cura di). La neutralità dello sport. Roma: Corocci, 2023.
Berg, Adam. “Non-ideal theory, cultural studies, and the transgender inclusion debate”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 50(3), 2023, 419-437.
Biale, Enrico. “A reflexive account of intra-party deliberation”. Political Parties and Deliberative Democracy in Europe. Routledge, 2024, 109-123.
Biale, Enrico. “Il valore di una leale partigianeria per una società democratica”. Notizie di Politeia, 37(144), 2021, 62-72.
Biale, Enrico. Interessi democratici e ragioni partigiane. Una concezione politica della democrazia. Bologna: Il Mulino, 2018.
Binney, Nicholas. “Fairness in handicap and championship sport”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 52(1), 2025, 60-79.
Borge, Steffen. “How to be a fictionalist about sport: response to Archer and Wojtowicz”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 2025, 1-9.
Borge, Steffen. The philosophy of football. London: Routledge, 2019.
Bowman-Smart, Hilary et al. “World Athletics regulations unfairly affect female athletes with differences in sex development”, Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 51(1), 2024, 29-53.
Burke, Michael. “‘A vision of paradise lost’: coaching as a grasshopper rather than an ant”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 49(1), 2022, 52-67.
Burke, Michael. “Trans women participation in sport: A feminist alternative to Pike’s position”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 49(2), 2022, 212-229.
Cartlidge, James. “Gamesmanship in Professional Darts: A Response to Leota, Turp and Howe”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 16(4), 2022, 489-502.
D’Agostino, Fred. “The ethos of games”, Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 8(1), 1981, 7-18.
Davis, Paul. “A Partisan’s Paradox”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 2025, 1-15.
Davis, Paul. “The purist/partisan spectator discourse: Some examination and discrimination”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 13(2), 2019, 247-258.
De Donato, Renato. “Embodied wisdom: philosophical reflections on boxing as a formative educational practice”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 51(3), 2024, 539-554.
De Hon Olivier et al. “Prevalence of doping use in elite sports: a review of numbers and methods”. Sports Medicine, 45(1), 2015, 57-69.
Del Bò, Corrado, Filippo Santoni de Sio. La partita perfetta: filosofia del calcio. Torino: Utet, 2018.
Devine, John William. “Elements of excellence”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 49(2), 2022, 195-211.
Dixon, Nicholas. “A moral critique of mixed martial arts”. Public affairs quarterly, 29(4), 2015, 365-384.
Dixon, Nicholas. “The ethics of supporting sports teams”. Journal of Applied Philosophy, 2001, 149-158.
Duncan, Samuel. “The spirit of play: Fun and freedom in the professional age of sport. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 16(3), 2022, 281-299.
Elbe, Anne-Marie, and Werner Pitsch. “Doping prevalence among Danish elite athletes”. Performance Enhancement & Health, 6(1), 2018, 28-32.
Elbe, Anne-Marie, and Werner Pitsch. “Doping prevalence among Danish elite athletes”. Performance Enhancement and Health: 6(1), 2018, 28-32.
Elstein, David. “On esports and competitive cooking: once more on the nature of sport”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 52(1), 2025, 98-113.
English, Jane. “Sex equality in sports”. Philosophy and Public Affairs, 7(3), 1978, 269-277.
Evans, Robert, & Michael McNamee. “Sports betting, horse racing and nanobiosensors–an ethical evaluation”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 15(2), 2021, 208-226.
Findler, Patrick. “Climbing high and letting die”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 48(1), 2021, 10-25.
Findler, Patrick. “Risky rescues revisited”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 50(2), 2023, 247-255.
Flynn, Erin. “Athletic skill and the value of close contests”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 48(2), 2021, 186-201.
Fruh, Kyle, Alfred Archer, and Jake Wojtowicz. “Sportswashing: Complicity and corruption”. Sport, ethics and philosophy, 17(1), 2023, 101-118.
Gordon, Emma & Connie Dodds. “High altitude, enhancement, and the ‘spirit of sport’”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 50(1), 2023, 63-82.
Hemmingsen, Michael. “Cheaters never prosper? Winning by deception in purely professional games of pure chance”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 15(2), 2021, 266-284.
Hemmingsen, Michael. “Code is law: Subversion and collective knowledge in the ethos of video game speedrunning”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 15(3), 2021, 435-460.
Hemmingsen, Michael. “Mapping the terrain of sport: a core-periphery model”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 51(1), 2024, 102-124.
Hemmingsen, Michael. “Towards a value-neutral definition of sport”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 19(1), 2024, 4-19.
Hemmingsen, Michael. “What is a metagame?”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 18(5), 2024, 452-467.
Huizinga, Johan, Homo Ludens: A Study of the Play-Element in Culture, Boston: Beacon Press, 1950 (1938)
Imbrišević, Miroslav. “Patriarchy in disguise: Burke on Pike and World Rugby”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 17(2), 2022, 204-222.
IOC ‘IOC Framework on Inclusion, Fairness and Non-Discrimination on the Basis of Gender Identity and Sex Variations’ 2021.
IOC ‘Gender Equality Through Time’ 2024, https://www.olympics.com/ioc/gender-equality/gender-equality-through-time accessed 04 June 2025,
Isidori, Emenuele, Heather L. Reid. Filosofia dello sport. Milano: Bruno Mondadori, 2011.
Johnson, Christopher & Jason Taylor. “Spilled milk and burned toast: extrinsic pressure and sporting excellence”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 48(2), 2021, 202-218.
Johnson, Daniel. M. “Three kinds of competitive excellence”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 47(2), 2020, 200-216.
Kayser, Bengt & Andreas De Block. “Would relaxation of the anti-doping rule lead to red queen effects?”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 15(3), 371-385.
Kind, Adrian & Eric R. Helms. “Is bodybuilding a sport?”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 50(2), 2023, 281-299.
Knox, Taryn, and Lynley Anderson. “Kid’s cage-fighting: it should be banned, right?”. Sport, ethics and philosophy, 16(3), 2022, 300-317.
Kobiela, Filip. “The paradox of the perfect game”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 50(3), 2023, 438-453.
Kolbinger, Otto. “The phenomenon of trivial offenses and why we should not just leave it to the referees”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 48(1), 2021, 82-96.
Kolers, Avery. “Magnificent Utopian games”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 49(2), 2022, 263-277.
Kung, Peter, and Shawn E. Klein. “The puzzle of sports fandom”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 52(1), 2025, 114-134.
Lash, Christopher. La cultura del narcisismo. L’individuo in fuga dal sociale in un’età di disillusioni collettive. Milano: Bompiani, 2001.
Lebed, Felix. “Dialectics in Transformations of Professional Sport”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 16(4), 2022, 589-606.
Leota, Josh. & Michael John Turp. “Gamesmanship as strategic excellence”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 47(2), 2020, 232-247.
Lewandowski, Joseph D. “Between rounds: the aesthetics and ethics of sixty seconds”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 47(3), 2020, 438-450.
Lis-Clarke, Ned & Adrian Walsh. “At Odds? Sports, Gambling and Hyper-Commodification”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 18(2), 2024, 210-228.
Lopez Frías, Francisco Javier. “Psychoanalyzing the Grasshopper: Society, work and repressed play in Suits’ riddle”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 15(2), 2021, 251-265.
Lopez Frías, Francisco Javier. “Ants, grasshoppers, asshoppers, and crickets cohabit in Utopia: the anthropological foundations of Bernard Suits’ analyses of gameplay and good living”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 49(1), 2022, 117-133.
Lopez Frías, Francisco Javier. “Does play constitute the good life? Suits and Aristotle on autotelicity and living well”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 47(2), 2020, 168-182.
Luzzi, Federico. “Conflating and misgendering: why World Athletics (and other sports governing bodies) should jettison the competitive labels ‘Women’s’/‘Men’s’”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 49(3), 2022, 366-382.
Luzzi, Federico. “On the justification for World Rugby’s ban on trans women: assessing key arguments in the debate”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 52(1), 2025, 41-59.
MacRae, Sinclair A. “A functional analysis of cheating and corruption in sports”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 50(1), 2023, 116-132.
MacRae, Sinclair A. “Why the rules do not prohibit cheating in sports”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 18(5), 2024, 497-510.
Mareš, Lukáš & Emily Ryall. “‘Playing sport playfully’: on the playful attitude in sport”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 48(2), 2021, 293-306.
Mareš, Lukáš. “The Role of sport in a good life: Aristotle and Suits”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 16(4), 2022, 544-562.
Mareš, Lukáš., & Daniel D. Novotný. “What is sport? A response to Jim Parry”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 17(1), 2023, 34-48.
Martínková, Irena et al. “Sex and gender in sport categorization: aiming for terminological clarity”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 49(1), 2022, 134-150.
Matz, Lou. “The real ethical problems with strategic fouling in basketball”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 49(3), 2022, 322-335.
McQueen, Paddy. “The parental dilemma of talented children”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 51(3), 2024, 460-475.
Morrison, Jo & Eric Moore. “Is WADA creating and then prosecuting thought crimes?”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 50(3), 2023, 402-418.
Morrison, Jo. “Anti-Doping Policy, Health, and Harm”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 19(2), 2025, 185-198.
Muirhead, Russell & Nancy L. Rosenblum. A lot of people are saying: The new conspiracism and the assault on democracy. Princeton University Press, 2019.
Naraine, Michael L. “Actually, esports is sport: a response to Parry’s (2019) misguided view”. Sports Innovation Journal, 2, 2021, 33-44.
Parfit, Derek. Reasons and Persons. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1986.
Parry, Jim, and Jacob Giesbrecht. “Esports, real sports and the Olympic Virtual Series”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 50(2), 2023, 208-228.
Parry, Jim. “E-sports are not sports”. Sports, Ethics and Philosophy, 13(1), 2019, 3-18.
Parry, Jim. “Esports will not be at the Olympics”. Journal of Olympic Studies, 2(2), 2021, 1, 13.
Petersen, Thomas Søbirk & Francicsco Javier Lopez Frias. “Promoting fairness in sport through performance-enhancing substances: An argument for why sport referees ought to ‘Be on Drugs’”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 15(2), 2021, 199-207.
Petersen, Thomas Søbirk. “Are You Game–Theoretically? A Critical Discussion of A Game-theory-based Argument in Favour of Banning Doping”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 16(4), 2022, 563-574.
Pho, Alexander, and Benjamin A. White. “A critical note on a purported disanalogy between cycling and mixed martial arts”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 49(2), 2022, 177-194.
Pho, Alexander. “A Confucian mutualist theory of sport”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 50(2), 2023, 256-280.
Pike, Jon. “Safety, fairness, and inclusion: transgender athletes and the essence of Rugby”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 48(2), 2021, 155-168.
Pike, Jon. “Why ‘meaningful competition’ is not fair competition”, Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 50(1), 2023, 1-17.
Pitsch, Werner & John Gleaves. “If You’re Not First, You’re Last: Are the Empirical Premises Correct in the Ethics of Anti-Doping?”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 15(4), 2021, 495-506.
Ramsay, Marc. “The line of permissibility: Gladiators, boxers, and MMA fighters”. The Philosophy of Mixed Martial Arts. Routledge, 2021, 88-104.
Ramsay, Marc. “The shared innocence of cycling and mixed martial arts: a reply to Pho and White”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 51(1), 2024, 145-162.
Reichling, Philipp. “Risky rescues–a reply to Patrick Findler”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 49(3), 2022, 336-350.
Robb, Catherine et al. “Life outside the diamond is a wrench’: on experiencing talent loss in sports. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 52(1), 2025, 80-97.
Rosenberg, Danny & Pam R. Sailors. “What money can buy: technology and breaking the two hour ‘marathon’ record”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 49(1), 2021, 1-18.
Rosenblum, Nancy L. On the Side of the Angels. Princeton University Press, 2008.
Russell John S. “Are rules all an umpire has to work with?” Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 26(1), 1999, 27-49.
Rust, Joshua. “The intelligibility and adequacy of late-stage utopian games”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 51(3), 2024, 555-574.
Sbetti, Nicola. Giochi di potere. Olimpiadi e politica da Atene a Londra (1896 – 2012). Firenze: Lo Monnier, 2012.
Simon, Robert L. “Internalism and internal values in sport” Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 27(1), 2000, 1-16.
Simon, Robert L., Ceasar R. Torres Peter F. Hager. Fair Play: the Ethics of Sport, 4th edition. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 2015.
Suits, Bernard et al. Return of the grasshopper: Games, Leisure and the Good Life in the Third Millennium. PLACE: Routledge, 2022.
Suits, Bernard, “Tricky Triad: Games, Play and Sport”, Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 15(1), 1988, 1-9.
Suits, Bernard, The Grasshopper: Games, Life and Utopia. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1978.
Suits, Bernard. “The Trick of the Disappearing Goal”, Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 156(1), 1989, 1-12.
Thau, Tena. “Rethinking the unfair advantage argument”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 48(1), 2021, 63-81.
Tillman, Micah D. “Easy games are still games for Suits”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 50(3), 2023, 329-344.
Tillman, Micah D. “Suits and the phenomenology of games: a reply to Johnson and Hudecki”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 49(2), 2022, 230-245.
Torres, Cesar R. et al. “Beyond physiology: Embodied experience, embodied advantage, and the inclusion of transgender athletes in competitive sport”. Sport, ethics and philosophy, 16(1), 2022, 33-49.
Turp, Michael-John. “Meaning and morality in boxing”. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 18(5), 2024, 468-482.
Ulrich, Rolf et al. “Doping in two elite athletics competitions assessed by randomized-response surveys”, Sports Medicine, 48(1), 2018, 211-19.
Walton, Kendall L. In other shoes: Music, metaphor, empathy, existence. Oxford University Press, 2015.
Walton, Kendall. “‘It’s Only a Game!’: Sports as Fiction”. In In Other Shoes: Music, Metaphor, Empathy, Existence, edited by K. Walton, 75-83. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2015.
White, Jonathan, and Lea Ypi. The meaning of partisanship. Oxford University Press, 2016.
Wildman, Nathan. “Don’t Stop Make-believing”. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 46(2), 2019, 261-275
Wittgenstein, Ludwig Philosophical Investigations. Oxford: Blackwell, 1953.
Yorke, Christopher C. “Endless summer: What kinds of games will Suits’ utopians play?” Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 44(2), 2017, 213-228.
Young, Iris Marion, “Throwing like a girl: a phenomenology of feminine body comportment motility and spatiality”. Human Studies, 3, 1980, 137-156.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Enrico Biale, Federico Luzzi

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

